
We read 95 critical reviews of Twin Cities electricians, plumbers and heating and cooling contractors. They are the reviews of three stars or fewer, and the negative comments, we found for 26 businesses on four public review sites, read on October 3, 2026.
Then we went through them again with one question: does the customer say what brought them to that contractor?
We found none that named an ad, a search or a mailer. The nearest were one mention of a lead directory, one of a retail store's service program, and a few people who were already customers: they came with a service plan, with the house, or had used the firm before. The rest said what went wrong and nothing about how they got there. In 72 of the 95, what went wrong was the price or the work.
Keep the limits in mind. These are complaints only, from one metro, and one firm accounts for 38 of the 95. It is a look, not a survey.
Our reading: that's normal. A customer writing a review is telling you about the job, not about your marketing. So your reviews can't tell you which ad paid. Neither can the ad's own report, which stops at clicks and calls. The only place that answer can live is your own job records. Here is a quick test of whether it lives there today.
Look at your last 50 jobs
Open your CRM and look at your last 50 jobs. Count how many have a lead source filled in. Then count how many of those say "Google" or "Other".
If most are blank, that isn't anyone's fault. On a slow Tuesday the field gets filled in. On the Monday after a storm, it doesn't. In many systems the field is optional, and nothing breaks when it's empty. So it stays empty, and at the end of the month you decide which ad to keep by feel.
That is the problem this page is about. The money goes out by source, and the jobs come back without one.
Calls aren't jobs, and jobs aren't revenue

Every marketing source has three numbers:
- Leads: the calls and web forms that came in from it.
- Booked jobs: the leads that turned into work on the schedule.
- Invoiced amount: what was invoiced for those jobs; it is not the same as payment received.
Most reports stop at the first number. Ad dashboards count clicks and calls. Directories count leads. The number you care about is the third one, and it lives in your CRM or your invoicing, where the ad reports can't see it.
The three numbers don't move together. A source can send the most calls and the least money, if its callers are shopping on price or its jobs are small. A source can send a handful of calls and pay back well, if its jobs are big. Judge by call count and you can cut the wrong one.
None of this counts the calls nobody answered. Those don't show up in any report. If you want that number, count the calls your shop is missing.
What "lead source" should mean

Pick one definition and write it down: the lead source is the first thing that made this customer contact you about this job.
Then set a few rules.
- Record it when the lead comes in. Not when the job closes. By then nobody remembers.
- Use a short, fixed list. Picked from a menu, never typed. Free text turns "Google", "google ads", "GOOGLE" and "internet" into four different sources.
- Split "Google" into what it really is. Search ads, your Google Business Profile, and your website found through search are three different sources with three different costs.
- Give repeat customers their own source. A past customer who looked up your number isn't a new lead from search. Credit search for them and you'll overpay for search.
- Name the referrer. "Referral" alone tells you little. "Referral: the property manager from the panel job" tells you who to thank.
- Keep one "Other" and read it. If "Other" keeps growing, something belongs on the list.
A sample list: Search ads · Google Business Profile · Website (found through search) · Facebook and Instagram ads · each paid directory, by name · Referral (with the name) · Repeat customer · Trucks and signage · Mailers · Other.
The lead-source field on a job holds one answer, so first contact is the right thing to store there.
Three ways to capture the source, from free to automatic
1. Ask, from a fixed list, every time. Free. Put the question in the phone script, make the field the first thing the office fills in, and check for blanks every Friday. It works as long as the habit holds, and it's only as accurate as the caller's memory. Plenty of people say "Google" for anything they found on a phone, whether it was your ad, your profile or a directory that came up in search.
2. Give each source its own tracked number and tagged link. This is call tracking. Your Business Profile gets one number, your ads get another, each directory gets its own, and every one of them forwards to your office line. Web forms carry a tag that shows which page or ad sent the visitor. Captured sources depend on the channel and setup; some leads may remain unlabelled.
3. Connect the source to the job and the invoice. For supported connections, a captured source can be carried to eligible jobs. Invoiced-amount reporting is being prepared for eligible accounts. This is the step that turns "calls by source" into "dollars by source". It's also the step most setups skip, because doing it by hand is tedious.
Is call tracking worth it for a small shop?
Call tracking costs money every month, so here's an honest way to decide.
It's probably worth it if:
- you pay for two or more marketing sources,
- you get enough calls that you can't remember where each one came from, and
- you've ever wondered which one to cut.
It's probably not worth it if you have one phone number, no paid marketing, and most of your work comes by word of mouth. There isn't much to measure yet.
The break-even is simple. Add up what your weakest source costs you in a year. If tracking costs less than that, it pays for itself the first time it shows you a source to cut.
One warning. Call tracking on its own tells you which source made the phone ring. It doesn't tell you which calls became paid jobs. If nobody connects the call to the invoice, you still end up judging sources by call count. We compare a plain call tracker with the other options in who we are and how we compare.
Will tracking numbers hurt my Google listing?
It's a fair worry. Local search leans on your business name, address and phone being consistent, and a tracked number is a different phone number.
Google's guidelines for representing your business (opens in a new tab), as we read them on October 3, 2026, ask for a phone number that connects to your individual business location and is under the direct control of the business. Our reading: a tracked number that rings your office line meets both. That is our reading, not a ruling from Google. A setup local-search specialists recommend is to put the tracked number in your Business Profile's primary phone field and your main office number in the first additional phone field, so both numbers on the profile are yours.
Two more rules.
First, never use a number you can't take with you. Ask any provider what happens to your tracked numbers if you leave. Here is our answer. If you leave, you can move your numbers to another phone provider. We charge nothing to release them, and the carriers charge nothing today. We never hold a number back over an unpaid balance. Numbers issued during a free trial are the one exception: they are not moved. So during a trial we put them only where we can switch them back, on your website and in your ads.
When your service ends we keep your numbers reserved for you for 30 days, and calls keep forwarding to your own line. Come back in that time and you pick up on the same numbers with no setup fee. If a move to another provider is under way, we keep holding until it finishes. After that the numbers are released.
Second, don't swap numbers on every listing at once without a plan for which number goes where.
A one-page monthly check
Once a month, fill in one table: source, spend, leads, booked jobs, invoiced revenue, and revenue per dollar spent. Decide your keep-or-cut line before you look at the numbers, so the numbers make the call and not your mood that week. Give a new source two or three months before you judge it. One slow month isn't a verdict.
Where FonsHive fits
Go back to your last 50 jobs and the blank field.
Here is how we cover it. For supported forms and bookings, FonsHive can carry the captured source into the CRM you already use. Call-to-job and invoiced-amount reporting are being prepared for eligible accounts. Unavailable sources remain unknown.
What we can connect depends on your CRM, its plan and the access you give us. We check and tell you before you start.